Over 38% of music on TikTok is ‘modified’, says research that analyzed 100 million recordings on the platform

MBW’s Stat Of The Week is a sequence during which we spotlight a knowledge level that deserves the eye of the worldwide music trade. Stat Of the Week is supported by music information analytics agency Chartmetric.

There has been a variety of debate this week concerning the extent to which TikTok can be impacted by the mixed removing of Universal Music Group’s publishing rights (spanning round 4 million songs) and recorded music repertoire (protecting round 3 million recordings).

A TikTok spokesperson informed us this week that “within the US and UK, UMG and UMPG mixed [comprises] roughly 30% of widespread music on the platform, and even much less in all places else”.

Senior music trade sources, nevertheless, have disagreed with this evaluation. Speaking to MBW, quite a lot of music execs have estimated that someplace between 60% and 80% of “related repertoire” on TikTok – i.e. present and confirmed hits – can be impacted by TikTok’s removing of UMG’s (mixed) publishing and recorded music repertoire.

In an evaluation of the UMG vs TikTok state of affairs revealed this week, J.P. Morgan analyst Daniel Kerven estimated that TikTok “would lose entry to a complete of 5 million songs” on account of the removing of the UMG recordings catalog, mixed with the deletion of extra UMPG repertoire.

Obviously sufficient, if a UMPG-signed songwriter writes or co-writes a success whose recording is launched through a non-UMG label (for instance, Dua Lipa’s present single, Training Season, launched on Warner Records however co-written by UMPG-signed Danny L Harle) that monitor might want to come down from TikTok as UMPG’s license with the service expires.

On Universal’s This autumn 2023 earnings name on Wednesday (February 28), Michael Nash, EVP and Chief Digital Officer of UMG, requested analysts to fastidiously contemplate the factors of any market share estimate of UMG’s repertoire on TikTok.

Said Nash: “Are you speaking about widespread music as we give it some thought? Or are you speaking about all audio content material – [which] would possibly embody sound results and a variety of AI content material?

“Obviously, we don’t suppose that [kind of non-copyrighted audio] needs to be a part of any artist royalty pool calculation.”

What Nash didn’t point out: copyrighted music that has then been modified by AI instruments – with its pitch or pace adjusted – and subsequently uploaded to TikTok. And which, on account of that modification, evades easy copyright detection (and market share attribution) on companies like TikTok.

So how a lot of the music on TikTok is ‘modified’ on this method? According to 1 trade analytics platform… a fabric quantity.

According to a new research from Pex, which displays and analyzes copyrighted content material on digital companies, TikTok has essentially the most modified audio of all main UGC platforms, together with YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram.

Pex estimates that comfortably greater than a 3rd (38.03%) of all songs discovered on TikTok had been pace or pitch-modified in 2023.

Not solely that, however Pex estimates that the share of tracks on TikTok which are modified is rising – up from 24.55% in 2022 to 38.03% in 2023 (see under).

Pex has confirmed to MBW that it analyzed a pattern of round 100 million tracks on TikTok for its newest research.

In complete Pex’s 2023 research monitored “a whole bunch of hundreds of thousands” of tracks throughout greater than 20 platforms (TikTok included) over a 12-month interval (Jan 2023 to Jan 2024).

According to Pex, modified audio usually isn’t straightforward to seek out through fundamental search.

On UGC platforms analyzed as a part of Pex’s evaluation, lower than 1% of recognized content material used key phrases within the title to point that it was the modified model of the unique.

“If we had been looking for modified audio by trying to find key phrases, we’d miss hundreds of thousands of songs or should hear to each monitor to listen to its pace and pitch,” defined Pex in its report.

Pex estimates that simply 0.16% of recognized content material contained “sped up” or “nightcore” within the title, and 0.11% had “slowed”, “reverb”, or “slowed+reverb” within the title.

Adds Pex: “This is the place content material identification expertise comes into play: solely ACR or MRT expertise like we use at Pex can match content material by analyzing the audio itself, versus simply key phrases.”

Two large questions are triggered by this new data from Pex, then:

• How a lot of that changed audio on TikTok (and different UGC platforms) relies on robustly copyrighted materials?
• And how a lot of that robustly copyrighted materials is owned by Universal Music Group?

Pex CEO Rasty Turek featured on the MBW podcast final 12 months, which you’ll be able to take heed to right here.

In that episode, we mentioned modified audio on audio platforms (not video platforms), and Turek defined the copyright implications of what Pex estimates to be over 1,000,000 tracks on audio streaming companies like Spotify, Apple Music, and TIDAL.

Unless these million-plus tracks have legally licensed the unique recording on which they’re primarily based, they’re infringing copyright.

This doesn’t solely have an effect on music streaming. It additionally impacts UGC social platforms like TikTok, as highlighted by Pex’s research.

“Rising in recognition, modified audio remixes usually divert royalty funds away from rightsholders and into the palms of different creators,” says Pex.

“Many of those songs aren’t licensed, and as such the possession data for them directs to the creator of the modified monitor, to not any of the unique rightsholders.

“Without a license or correct attribution, rightsholders received’t see any credit score or cost from using their songs.”

Chartmetric is the all-in-one platform for artists and music trade professionals, offering complete streaming, social, and viewers information for everybody to create profitable careers in music.Music Business Worldwide