Revealing Brooklyn’s Best Hidden Thrift Store Gems in 2023

Revealing Brooklyn’s Best Hidden Thrift Store Gems in 2023

One of the issues that makes Brooklyn stand out – not solely in New York however worldwide – is thrift shops.

I’ll always remember when I discovered an genuine Chanel blazer in a pile of garments for 10 bucks. Even higher, I wore it to a job interview the following day and landed the job!

But as thrilling as it might be, it will also be fairly complicated and overwhelming attempting to determine which shops are good, rummage by way of the gadgets successfully, and get the most effective offers attainable.

That is particularly true for thrifting in Brooklyn, because it has a number of the world’s most various and greatest thrift shops.

Furniture, vinyl records, books, clothes, and classic jewellery are cool stuff you’ll encounter in your Brooklyn thrifting journey.

But don’t fear – you’re in the appropriate place. In this text, I’ll share every thing you want about Brooklyn thrift shops – together with some thrifting dos and don’ts!

View of Downtown Brooklyn

Key Takeaway

  • Brooklyn has a number of the greatest and most various thrift shops on this planet, the place you may discover unimaginable offers on garments, furnishings, books, records, and extra.
  • Some prime thrift shops in Brooklyn embrace Monk Vintage Thrift Shop, L Train Vintage, Buffalo Exchange, Housing Works, Beacon’s Closet, and Urban Jungle.
  • Lesser identified thrift gems embrace City Opera Thrift Shop, Cure Thrift, Awoke Vintage, No Relation Vintage, 10 FT Single by Stella, and Unearth Vintage.
  • For a full day of thrifting in Brooklyn, begin in Williamsburg, discover shops on Bedford Ave, head to Bushwick, and finish in DUMBO. The greatest occasions to go are weekday mornings and evenings.
  • Brooklyn thrifting allows you to discover distinctive classic gadgets whereas supporting small companies, native artists, and even charitable organizations. It’s an expertise that embodies the borough’s inventive spirit.

Thrift Stores in Brooklyn: Lesser Known Hidden Gems

We’ve established that Brooklyn is the “it” place for thrifting, which is why some retailers are extremely well-known and well-liked amongst thrifters.

But these locations aren’t the one ones value poking your head in.

Here are a few of my favourite thrift shops in Brooklyn that aren’t as well-known however undoubtedly deserve your consideration.

Monk Vintage Thrift Shop

Secondhand shopping at Monk Vintage

Source: yelp.com 

Location: 500 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Monk Vintage is a small however well-curated thrift retailer with an enormous collection of classic clothes, equipment, and residential items. The costs are additionally very cheap – plus, you may donate your clothes and get a 25% low cost in your subsequent buy!

Not solely can you discover unimaginable clothes gadgets there, however you too can discover the good suitcase in your upcoming travels, hats and jewellery to amp up any outfit, and even a classic film poster that can make everybody envy your crib.

What’s even higher is that Monk has a number of the greatest seasonal alternatives – which implies you would possibly simply discover your new favourite ugly Christmas sweater there!

City Opera Thrift Shop

Designer items at City Opera

Source: yelp.com

Location: 513 W twenty sixth St, New York, NY 10001

City Opera Thrift Shop is a type of uniquely New York locations. Just set foot inside the shop, and also you’ll know what I imply.

They’re identified for popping out with curated classic collections all year long, all centered round completely different inspirational subjects.

If you’re looking for designer and high-end items, it’s probably the greatest thrift shops in Brooklyn. Give it a shot even in case you’re on a tighter finances, although – they’ve an important, reasonably priced choice, too!

Cure Thrift

Girl trying on a vintage beret

Source: yelp.com

Location: 91 Third Ave, New York, NY 10003

If you need to spend the day thrifting within the Big Apple – and also you care about giving again – Cure Thrift is the place to go.

The retailer proprietor, Liz Wolff, was recognized with Type 1 diabetes when she was a baby – so when she began the classic buying enterprise, she knew she needed to make it significant.

That’s how Cure Thrift grew to become one of many few non-profit classic shops that donate its earnings to the Diabetes Research Institute.

If you want extra convincing after this, I’ll let you know a bit about what yow will discover within the retailer: classic artwork, jewellery, house decor, rugs, high-end clothes – and a lot extra.

You can go to Cure Thrift on-line for an in depth have a look at their supply – however don’t skip the in-person go to. It’s an expertise like no different.

Awoke Vintage

Awoke thrift stores in Brooklyn

Source: yelp.com

Location: 132 N fifth St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

This lovable thrift retailer was established all the best way in Perth, Australia, in 2007. In 2012, the proprietor, Liz Power, took a leap of religion and relocated her enterprise to Brooklyn, NY.

What units it aside from the remaining is that it focuses on denim, so in case you’re on the hunt for the right pair of denims to reside in, head over to Awoke.

But denims aren’t the one factor this thrift retailer is sweet for. You can discover nuggets of gold – not actually, however possibly in case you look fastidiously sufficient – for $5 or $10, or you may try their fastidiously curated collection of small Brooklyn-based manufacturers.

No Relation Vintage

No Relation thrift shops

Source: foursquare.com

Location: 654 Sackett St, Brooklyn, NY 11217

No Relation Vintage is a part of the family-owned L Train Vintage, which is without doubt one of the greatest classic retailers in New York. There are literally two completely different thrift shops: one in East Village and one in Gowanus.

Don’t be deterred by the placement, although:

The No Relation in Gowanus is unquestionably well worth the go to. The retailer is in a warehouse – which provides to the attraction – however most significantly, it’s stuffed with nice items.

You simply need to know what to search for, and also you’ll discover it right here!

10 FT Single by Stella

10 FT Single by Stella Dallas

Source: yelp.com

Location: 285 N sixth St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

10 FT Single has a improbable collection of males’s and ladies’s classic items, together with high-quality leather-based jackets, equipment, and jewellery.

Right subsequent door is its sister store, Stella Dallas Living, the place yow will discover superb classic furnishings, furnishing textiles, and classic girls’s clothes from the Forties!

What I like about this retailer is that, in contrast to some thrift retailers, 10 FT Single is organized into classes – good for classic buying rookies and people in search of a seamless thrifting expertise.

Unearth Vintage

Unearth, one of the best cheap thrift stores

Source: yelp.com

Location: Storefront, 159 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Are you a sucker for a pretty-looking retailer, like me?

Then you’re going to like Unearth Vintage in Cobble Hill, Boerum Hill. This 2,000-square-foot retailer is stuffed with probably the most various collection of clothes; it’s a treasure hunt!

It doesn’t matter in case your fashion is extra shabby chick or female traditional. You’ll discover one thing in Unearth.

This funky retailer, nevertheless, is identified for its assertion, distinctive classic finds that can not be seen in different Brooklyn thrift shops.

What’s even higher is that they get a whole lot of latest gadgets each week. So, even in case you don’t spot one thing you want in your first strive, I like to recommend paying one other go to to the shop and attempting once more!

Famous “Classic” Brooklyn Thrift Stores

Now that we’ve coated these hidden gems of Brooklyn thrift shops, we are able to transfer on to the massive weapons.

You’ve in all probability heard of a few of these classic shops – however I’ve additionally beforehand talked about a pair in connection to the lesser-known thrift shops.

Here’s my record of the greatest thrift shops in Brooklyn – all well-known for a motive!

Buffalo Exchange

Buffalo Exchange thrift

Source: buffaloexchange.com

Location: 109 Boerum Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Buffalo Exchange is a nationwide chain, however its Brooklyn areas are a number of the greatest. The shops have a big selection of classic and secondhand garments, footwear, and equipment.

You can discover every thing from designer labels to classic Levi’s denims.

Buffalo Exchange has been round since 1974, so that they know their stuff.

What makes this store distinctive is the buying fashion. Back within the 70s, Kerstin Block got here up with the thought to open a thrift retailer with a unique enterprise mannequin:

She allowed individuals to promote their garments for money or on-the-spot commerce, making Buffalo Exchange a resale store with an important collection of hand-picked clothes.

L Train Vintage

L Train Vintage NYC thrift stores

Source: ltrainvintagenyc.com

Location: 629 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

I’ve talked about L Train Vintage earlier than – however let’s get into extra element.

L Train Vintage is a Williamsburg establishment. The retailer has an enormous collection of classic clothes, house items, and furnishings.

You can discover every thing from classic Chanel attire to mid-century fashionable furnishings at L Train Vintage.

Their retailer in Williamsburg is tiny however mighty.

The area is neatly organized, which saves you a lot of time. You’ll be out and in along with your new steals very quickly.

You can discover charming items of classic clothes for an reasonably priced value – though L Train Vintage isn’t a type of well-known low-cost thrift shops.

Their choice is probably not everybody’s cup of tea; many quirky bits require a particular sort of individual to fall in love with them.

If that’s you, you’ll have a subject day right here!

Housing Works in Brooklyn Heights

Inside one of Housing Works thrift shops

Source: yelp.com

Location: 150 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Here’s a Brooklyn thrift retailer with a significant mission behind it:

Housing Works in Brooklyn Heights is a nonprofit group that helps individuals with HIV/AIDS.

The thrift shops have a big selection of garments, footwear, and equipment, each new and used. You can discover every thing from designer purses to classic jewellery at Housing Works.

Housing Works prides itself on its advocacy and lifesaving companies:

Besides clothes and books, the shop affords healthcare companies for individuals affected by AIDS/HIV and homelessness.

You already love thrifting – so why not assist this stellar neighborhood and retailer whereas discovering superior clothes?

They have a number of areas throughout New York, however the one in Brooklyn is value giving a shot!

Beacon’s Closet

Vintage pieces at Beacon's Closet

Source: foursquare.com

Location: 74 Guernsey St, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Beacon’s Closet is one other Brooklyn establishment.

The retailer has a massive collection of classic and secondhand garments, footwear, and equipment. You can discover every thing from designer attire to classic band T-shirts at Beacon’s Closet.

It’s been acknowledged by a number of the largest vogue magazines and websites – like Vogue, Goop, Refinery 29, W Magazine, and plenty of extra.

It’s not only a hyped-up retailer with no substance, although.

The proprietor, Carrie Peterson, began the thrift retailer with garments from her and her buddies’ assortment and private thrift finds in 1997, and even lived within the again for some time to make ends meet.

That’s how a lot she believed in Beacon’s Closet.

It has a number of areas throughout Brooklyn and New York, too.

The story, the environment of those shops, and the nice collection of hand-picked secondhand garments make this one in every of my favourite thrift shops in Brooklyn.

Urban Jungle

Urban Jungle thrift store

Source: yelp.com

Location: 118 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237

Urban Jungle is a thrift retailer and classic clothes retailer in Bushwick.

The retailer affords a big selection of classic garments, footwear, equipment, house items, and furnishings.

You can discover every thing from classic Levi’s denims to mid-century fashionable furnishings at Urban Jungle.

It’s a part of the L Train Vintage shops, which drastically explains their large choice.

Even extra so, Urban Jungle has bought to be one in every of – if not the largest – thrift shops in New York City. That ought to provide you with an thought of how a lot there’s to kind by way of right here.

What is even higher is that gadgets have cheap costs – whereas being in near-perfect situation.

I ought to warn you that you just’ll in all probability spend your entire day right here – it’s large!

Tired Thrift

Tired Thrift store

Source: tiredthrift.com

Location: 10 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Tired Thrift is a thrift retailer in Williamsburg that focuses on Y2K vogue. It’s mainly the product of simultaneous frustration and love for the garments of two native New Yorkers.

They’re on a mission to deliver again authenticity to vogue within the face of mass manufacturing.

The retailer boasts a big selection of classic garments, footwear, and equipment from the late Nineties and early 2000s.

With their classic items from the ’90s and ’00s, you’re assured to really feel these nostalgic vibes and journey down reminiscence lane in case you’re a millennial or an early Gen Z child.

The retailer is properly organized, too – and also you already know the way necessary that’s to me.

All in all, it’s best to put Tired Thrift retailer in your thrift buying record.

Grand Street Local

Location: 154 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Grand Street Local is a thrift retailer in Williamsburg that focuses on classic clothes and residential items.

Oh, and it’s a family-owned enterprise with classic garments courting way back to the Forties, too!

I’ve discovered a few of my most worn T-shirts on this retailer. If you’re keen on nothing greater than to throw on a pair of denims and a unusual Tee, you’ll have your fingers full at Grand Street Local.

If you’re desperate to see what they’ve of their present choice, you may go to their Instagram web page – and whilst you’re there, you may take part in a reside public sale each Sunday night time.

The vitality within the retailer is nice, and the workers is pleasant. You’ll love being there – not only for the garments!

Brooklyn Flea

Vintage items on sale at flea market

Source: yelp.com

Location: 80 Pearl St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Now for a little bit change – we’re going full-on retro!

Brooklyn Flea is a flea market that takes place on weekends in Williamsburg and DUMBO. The flea market is stuffed with distributors promoting every thing from antiques to classic garments.

It takes place outdoors, which already makes it completely different from most different locations I’ve instructed you about. Plus, any such thrifting is one thing your grandma in all probability took half in her days.

I like the Brooklyn Flea as a result of it’s an expertise like no different.

My buddies and I typically plan it as a whole-day factor, particularly when the climate is good. The incontrovertible fact that there’s scrumptious contemporary meals there, as properly, is simply an added bonus.

In basic, the factor with flea markets is that it’s not as regulated as buying in shops – nevertheless it’s fairly value it. You can discover many gadgets – garments, antiques, house decor, books, and records!

Stella Dallas

Location: 281 N sixth St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Stella Dallas needs to be a well-recognized title by now – however right here, I’ll let you know in regards to the Stella Dallas Living thrift retailer. Thrifting in Brooklyn wouldn’t be full with out some house items, proper?

Well, this retailer is the right place for that.

Upcycling classic house gadgets and furnishings is tremendous enjoyable. You could make it a DIY undertaking along with your family and friends!

However, this isn’t the one factor yow will discover right here:

Stella has some ultra-charming classic girls’s clothes from the Forties, too. So, if that’s your fashion – otherwise you wish to emulate Ava Gardner – you’re positive to reach your search right here.

Aside from that, the shop has a big selection of classic attire, in addition to classic footwear and equipment.

A Local’s Recommended Itinerary To a Perfect Day Thrifting in Brooklyn

Girl filling out her planner

Okay, by now, you’re conscious that Brooklyn is a thrifting paradise – house to numerous classic retailers and secondhand shops simply ready to be explored.

I would like you to have the most effective day, so I’m providing you with an insider itinerary for a full day of thrifting Brooklyn’s greatest spots whereas experiencing native tradition:


  • Start your day with a espresso and pastry at one of many many cafes in Williamsburg. I like to recommend St. Anselm, identified for its scrumptious espresso and pastries, in addition to its fashionable and alluring environment. I imply, you’re in Brooklyn, in spite of everything.
  • Once you’re correctly caffeinated, head over to the L Train Vintage. This retailer has an enormous collection of classic clothes, house items, and furnishings; you’re certain to search out one thing you’re keen on.
  • After L Train Vintage, you may stroll down Bedford Avenue to Beacon’s Closet. This retailer is one other Brooklyn staple – and it’s identified for its vary of classic and secondhand garments, footwear, and equipment.


  • Grab a chew to eat in one in every of Williamsburg’s atmospheric eating places. If you’re up for extra mainstream meals, L’Industrie Pizzeria is the place to go.
  • Done with lunch? Then, head to Bushwick to discover the neighborhood’s many thrift shops. Monk Vintage Thrift Shop is the place to be. It has a well-curated collection of classic clothes, equipment, and residential items.
  • After Monk, you may take a stroll down Myrtle Avenue to Urban Jungle. There, you’ll discover a variety of things – garments, furnishings, and rather more.


  • For dinner, head again to Williamsburg. I like to recommend Chez Ma Tante, which serves up scrumptious French-inspired delicacies in an enthralling and romantic setting.
  • After dinner, you may stroll alongside the East River waterfront and benefit from the magical views of Manhattan. Before heading house, you too can cease by St. Anselm once more for a nightcap.

That’s only a steered itinerary; be at liberty to customise it to suit your pursuits and finances.

For instance, in case you’re on a decent finances, you may pack your personal lunch and go to a number of the free museums and sights in Brooklyn, such because the Brooklyn Museum and the Prospect Park Zoo.

You’ll have a good time thrifting in Brooklyn both manner!

Insider Tips: Days and Times to Go Thrifting in Brooklyn

Here’s what to remember when making a plan:

  • Weekday mornings (Mon-Wed) – You’ll get the primary decide of latest stock. Besides, it’s much less crowded than on weekends.
  • Thursday evenings – Many thrift shops put out new merch or mark down gadgets on Thursdays, which implies good availability.
  • Fridays – It’s a enjoyable day to thrift, however keep in mind that the shops begin filling up for the weekend. If you need to go on a Friday, go earlier.
  • Saturdays – Saturday is a well-liked day, so be as early as attainable. There’s tons to select from, however be ready for a crowd.
  • Sundays – Another busy day. Some thrift shops have gross sales on Sunday mornings, making for an thrilling journey and insufferable crowds.
  • End of month (final week) – More donations and truck unloading occur at month’s finish, providing you with the right alternative to bag some superior offers.
  • Holiday weekends – Try thrifting on the precise vacation when most different shops are closed. Less competitors means much less stress.
  • Cold winter weekdays – These are usually slower thrifting days. Besides, the workers could also be prepared to barter costs. If bargaining is your factor, that is your time to shine.

Don’t neglect to search for the shop’s working hours and schedule; the very last thing you need is to make a plan – solely to reach on the retailer and discover it closed.


Thrifting is a delight – however recognizing the most effective thrift retailers to go to is a ability in its personal proper.

Additionally, the spirit of thrifting, neighborhood, and doing one thing good – not just for the atmosphere however for different individuals, as properly – is an added bonus. And as you noticed, there are quite a few shops that assist a larger trigger.

Not solely that, however you get to satisfy this charming a part of New York, which is bursting with tradition and artwork!

Put all that in a singular atmosphere comparable to Brooklyn, and also you’ll see that nothing compares.

Thrifting in Brooklyn is like consuming pizza in Italy or ingesting wine in France – in a league of its personal!

So, there you could have it: my information to the most effective thrift shops in Brooklyn. Let me learn about your go-to thrift retailer within the feedback under!


through Sammy D. Vintage https://ift.tt/4kwjStD

November 16, 2023 at 07:26PM

Select your currency